Is the INTJ Tendency Toward Withdrawal and Overthinking Really That Bad?
Lately, I have been thinking a lot about the structure of INTJ types and the way our traits develop throughout life. How the different parts of our personality communicate with one another, and how we move between different mental states.
There is a lot of talk in the MBTI community about the introverted “thoughts-and-feelings loop” of the INTJ — the state in which we withdraw inward, disconnect from the world, and analyze our emotions in loops — as simply something negative that should be avoided at all costs. But I would like to suggest another way of looking at it.
What if this loop is inevitable?
What if it is a “necessary evil” for potential growth and development?
What if it is simply the natural flow of our maturation?
To be clear — every trait can be both positive and negative. I am in no way claiming that being stuck in a closed loop that feeds itself and creates sadness or disconnection is healthy.
However, I do think that this extreme state is less common than it is often described. Our practical and rational part — the Te function, the need to act and think logically in relation to the world — does not simply “shut off” completely at any stage. Continued external experience — new experiences and new information from reality — prevents this withdrawal from being truly isolated from influence.
Both from personal experience and from information I have heard from other INTJs, it seems that our personality develops in a fairly clear order throughout life:
-
Early childhood: strategic vision and deep intuition — the Ni function, the tendency to search for patterns and meaning — are dominant.
-
Early adolescence: the strong need for logic, efficiency, and external order — the Te function — begins to develop.
-
Late adolescence to the early twenties: the inner world of feeling and personal values awakens. This is where the deep search for identity and self-meaning begins — the Fi function.
-
Late twenties: healthy logic and the ability to execute and bring things into reality return to function in a more mature and balanced way.
We can assume that our connection to the here and now, to the body and to physical reality — the Se function — also begins to develop around this period, from the late twenties into the thirties. Our rational and executive part needs this connection to reality in order to gather real information from the world and then process it into deep insights.
In order to become a balanced person, we need to explore and face different aspects of the self and the psyche. A deep exploration of our inner world is required. This thought-and-feeling loop provides exactly that — an opportunity to stop, grasp our inner emotions, and try to understand them.
At first, this will probably appear in unhealthy ways: outbursts, anger, repression, or other childish and avoidant behaviors. But this is likely simply the result of unfamiliarity with the emotional world, and of the fact that our ability to manage emotions is still in its early stages of development.
As INTJs mature, they learn to recognize their emotions and come to terms with them. A person must face difficulty and challenge in order to grow.
The Hero’s Journey
You are not broken, and you are not defective.
You are human; occupied with trying to understand yourselves and your personal meaning. Trying to cope with a reality that is sometimes difficult, and with the complex nature and meaning of the “self.”
“The roots must first reach deep down, and only then can the tree grow tall.” — Carl Jung
We must first descend into the depths so that we can later grow upward. This is a necessary retreat into the depths of the self. Our inner parts — intuition and deep feeling, the Ni and Fi functions — are the roots, while our executive and rational ability to act in the world is the tree itself, the Te and Se functions.
This is a natural stage that every INTJ will go through — a period that begins around early adolescence and continues into the twenties.
A successful acceptance and integration of the inner emotional world will eventually lead to the successful, healthy, and mature development of our rational and executive side, and of our self-expression in the world. In this state, our strong intuition tries to bring order to the chaotic and dark landscape of inner feeling.
It is a complex inner journey — but an immensely worthwhile one.
Feel like this is only the tip of the iceberg? Let’s keep talking about it. We opened a WhatsApp group for people who understand — and are interested in — MBTI, where you can dive deeper into the types and ask about anything that interests you, without holding back.